Backyard Discovery Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set vs Backyard Discovery Atlantis Cedar Swing Set (2026): Key Differences
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are comparing the backyard discovery mount mckinley cedar swing set vs atlantis cedar models from Backyard Discovery. Both sets share 100% cedar construction, an 8-foot wave slide, and a 5-year warranty. They also include two belt swings and a trapeze. The main difference lies in their layout and climbing features. The Mount McKinley offers a wider footprint with a double rock wall, while the Atlantis features a clubhouse design with a narrower width. Choose based on your yard space and preferred play style.
Key differences
| Aspect | Backyard Discovery Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set | Backyard Discovery Atlantis Cedar Swing Set |
|---|---|---|
| Assembled Dimensions | 150 in W x 186 in L x 119 in H | 93.5 in W x 217 in L x 111 in H |
| Climbing Wall | Double rock wall with 9 holds | Single rock wall with 6 holds |
| Elevated Structure | Play deck with canopy, steering wheel, and telescope | Clubhouse with bay windows and balcony |
| Access Method | Wide step ladder and rope ladder | Flat-step ladder |
| Weight | 308 pounds | 297 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Backyard Discovery Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set if
- You need a wider play structure for multiple children to climb simultaneously
- You prefer a lower play deck with a canopy and interactive accessories like a telescope
- Your yard has limited length but sufficient width
Choose Backyard Discovery Atlantis Cedar Swing Set if
- You want a raised clubhouse experience with bay windows and a balcony
- Your yard has limited width but ample length for a longer structure
- You prefer a simpler access ladder without a rope component
Verdict: The Mount McKinley suits yards with wider footprints and offers more complex climbing with its double rock wall. The Atlantis fits narrower spaces with its elongated design and provides a clubhouse-style elevated area. Select the Mount McKinley for multi-climber capacity or the Atlantis for a compact, themed playhouse layout.
Mount McKinley vs Atlantis Cedar
Footprint and size
The Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set measures 150 inches wide by 186 inches long. The Atlantis Cedar Swing Set is narrower at 93.5 inches wide but extends further in length to 217 inches. You should measure your yard carefully before choosing. The Mount McKinley offers a wider play area, which might feel less cramped for side-by-side activities. The Atlantis requires more linear space but leaves more width free. Consider how you plan to arrange the set near fences or trees. Both are substantial structures, but their shapes fit different yard layouts.
Climbing features
The Mount McKinley includes a double rock climbing wall with nine holds and a rope assist, plus a separate rope ladder with wooden rungs. The Atlantis features a single rock climbing wall with six holds. The Mount McKinley offers more vertical climbing challenges and variety for active kids who enjoy scaling heights. The Atlantis provides a simpler climbing experience that may suit younger children better. Both sets encourage physical activity, but the Mount McKinley’s dual climbing elements provide more options for simultaneous play. The rope ladder on the Mount McKinley adds an extra layer of adventure not found on the Atlantis.
Playhouse design
The Mount McKinley features a raised play deck with a canopy roof, steering wheel, and toy telescope. The Atlantis includes a raised clubhouse with bay windows, a balcony, and a wooden roof. The Atlantis design mimics a traditional playhouse more closely, which may appeal to children who like imaginative role-playing. The Mount McKinley’s deck focuses more on open-air exploration with its telescope and steering wheel features. Both structures provide elevated spaces, but the Atlantis offers more enclosed, house-like elements. Choose the Atlantis if you prefer a cozy hideaway, or the Mount McKinley for a more open, nautical-themed adventure deck.
Swing configuration
The Mount McKinley includes two classic belt swings, one trapeze, and a web swing. The Atlantis includes two belt swings and one trapeze. The Mount McKinley offers an additional web swing, allowing for slightly more simultaneous swinging options. This extra swing can be beneficial for households with multiple children who want to play at the same time. The trapeze and belt swings are standard on both sets. The inclusion of the web swing on the Mount McKinley provides a unique swinging experience that the Atlantis lacks. If you prioritize maximum swinging capacity, the Mount McKinley has a slight advantage here.
Lower play area
The Mount McKinley features a shaded sandbox area for sensory play. The Atlantis includes a built-in sandbox area and a snack bar shelf for juice box breaks. The Atlantis offers more functional lower-level features with the addition of the snack bar. This shelf provides a convenient spot for drinks and small snacks during play. Both sets encourage sensory play with their sandboxes, though sand is not included. The Atlantis design integrates more utility into the lower level. If you value convenience for snack breaks, the Atlantis snack bar is a practical addition. The Mount McKinley focuses more on the sandbox experience without the extra shelf.
Weight and handling
The Mount McKinley weighs 308 pounds, while the Atlantis weighs 297 pounds. The Mount McKinley is slightly heavier, which may contribute to greater stability once installed. The Atlantis is marginally lighter, which could make assembly and positioning slightly easier. Both sets are constructed from durable cedar wood, ensuring long-term strength. The weight difference is minimal and unlikely to significantly impact your decision. You should consider the weight when planning for assembly, as both require two people. The slightly heftier Mount McKinley may feel more solid in windy conditions, while the Atlantis remains robust enough for standard residential use.
Which swing set fits your yard
You have a narrow but deep yard space
The Atlantis Cedar Swing Set measures 93.5 inches wide and 217 inches long. Its narrow footprint fits tighter side-to-side while extending further back. This layout suits properties with limited width but ample depth. You get the same 8-foot wave slide and cedar construction as the wider model, just in a different shape.
You want extra climbing holds and a sandbox
The Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set features a double rock climbing wall with 9 holds and a rope assist. It also includes a shaded sandbox area for sensory play. The Atlantis has only 6 holds and no sandbox. If you prioritize vertical climbing challenges and dedicated digging space, this wider deck offers more features.
You prefer a spacious raised play deck
The Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set offers a 150-inch width, creating a broad play deck. It includes a canopy roof, steering wheel, and toy telescope. The Atlantis is narrower at 93.5 inches. If you want more horizontal surface area for kids to gather on the upper level, the Mount McKinley provides a larger platform.
The products compared
Backyard Discovery Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set
Best for: large yards needing durable cedar play structures
- Material
- 100% cedar wood
- Number of Swings
- 2 belt swings, 1 trapeze, web swing
- Slide Type
- 8-foot wave slide
- Assembled Dimensions
- 150 in W x 186 in L x 119 in H
- Installation Type
- Ready to assemble
- Warranty
- 5-year warranty
View on Amazon: Backyard Discovery Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set Affiliate link
This 150 by 186 inch cedar swing set offers a spacious raised play deck with a canopy roof. It includes a 2-belt swing, 1 trapeze, and 1 web swing for multiple users. The 8-foot wave slide and double rock climbing wall add active play options. A shaded sandbox area sits below the deck. The structure is built from 100% cedar wood and comes with a 5-year warranty.
Pros
- Built from 100% cedar wood for natural decay resistance
- Includes 2 belt swings, 1 trapeze, and 1 web swing
- Features a double rock climbing wall with 9 holds and rope assist
- Has a spacious raised play deck with a canopy roof
- Comes with a 5-year manufacturer warranty
Cons
- Assembled dimensions require a large footprint of 150 by 186 inches
- Sand for the sandbox area is not included
- Requires assembly before use
Good fit if
- You have a large backyard space for a 150 by 186 inch structure
- You want a cedar wood set with a 5-year warranty
- You need multiple swinging options including a trapeze and web swing
Skip if
- You need a pre-assembled unit ready for immediate use
- You want a smaller footprint under 150 inches wide
- You prefer a set that includes sand for the sandbox
Verdict: Backyard Discovery Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set suits families with ample yard space who want a durable cedar build and extensive climbing and swinging features.
Backyard Discovery Atlantis Cedar Swing Set
Best for: large families needing multi-level play features
- Material
- Cedar wood
- Number of Swings
- 2 belt swings, 1 trapeze
- Slide Type
- 8-foot wave slide
- Age Range
- Up to 8 kids
- Installation Type
- Assembly required, residential use only
- Warranty
- 5-year warranty
View on Amazon: Backyard Discovery Atlantis Cedar Swing Set Affiliate link
The Backyard Discovery Atlantis is an extra-large cedar swing set featuring a raised clubhouse and lower play space. It includes a 93.5-inch wide structure with a rock wall and 8-foot wave slide. The set supports up to eight kids with two belt swings and a trapeze. Its 111-inch height and 297-pound weight provide a sturdy, multi-level play environment for residential backyards.
Pros
- Raised clubhouse with bay windows and balcony
- Built-in sandbox area and snack bar shelf
- Rock climbing wall with six holds
- Includes two belt swings and one trapeze
Cons
- Assembly required for residential use
- Sand for sandbox is not included
- Stain saturation and color may vary
Good fit if
- You want a raised clubhouse for elevated play
- You need space for up to eight children
- You prefer natural cedar wood construction
Skip if
- You prefer a pre-assembled ready-to-use set
- You have a small yard under 93.5 inches wide
- You do not want to build the structure yourself
Verdict: Backyard Discovery Atlantis Cedar Swing Set offers a comprehensive play experience with its raised clubhouse and lower sandbox area, making it ideal for families seeking a large, multi-feature cedar structure.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Backyard Discovery Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set | Backyard Discovery Atlantis Cedar Swing Set |
|---|---|---|
| Material | 100% cedar wood | Cedar wood |
| Number of Swings | 2 belt swings, 1 trapeze, web swing | 2 belt swings, 1 trapeze |
| Slide Type | 8-foot wave slide | 8-foot wave slide |
| Assembled Dimensions | 150 in W x 186 in L x 119 in H | not stated |
| Age Range | not stated | Up to 8 kids |
| Installation Type | Ready to assemble | Assembly required, residential use only |
| Warranty | 5-year warranty | 5-year warranty |
| Dimensions | 186 × 150 × 119 inches | 217 × 93.5 × 111 inches |
| Weight | 308 pounds | 297 pounds |
| Color | Light Brown | Brown |
| Model | 1705012 | 1608016B |
| Size | not stated | Extra Large |
Frequently asked questions
Which cedar swing set is better for a small yard?
The Atlantis Cedar Swing Set is better for smaller spaces. It measures 93.5 inches wide, making it narrower than the Mount McKinley. Its compact width allows it to fit into tighter side-to-side areas. The Mount McKinley is wider at 150 inches, requiring more lateral space. Choose the Atlantis if width is your main constraint.
Which swing set is taller?
The Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set is taller. It stands at 119 inches high. The Atlantis Cedar Swing Set reaches 111 inches. The extra height on the Mount McKinley provides more clearance for taller children or older kids. This difference matters if you have limited overhead clearance or want a more imposing structure.
Which model weighs more?
The Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set is heavier. It weighs 308 pounds. The Atlantis Cedar Swing Set weighs 297 pounds. The Mount McKinley is 11 pounds heavier. This slight difference may affect assembly effort or stability needs. Both sets are substantial structures, but the Mount McKinley has a marginally higher mass.
Which swing set is longer?
The Atlantis Cedar Swing Set is longer. It extends 217 inches in length. The Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set measures 186 inches long. The Atlantis provides 31 more inches of depth. You should choose the Atlantis if you have a deep yard. The Mount McKinley is shorter and may suit yards with less rear space.
Are both sets made of cedar?
Yes, both sets are made of cedar. The Mount McKinley Cedar Swing Set uses cedar construction. The Atlantis Cedar Swing Set also features cedar materials. This shared material choice offers durability and natural resistance to decay. You get the same wood quality in both models, ensuring consistent longevity for your backyard investment.
Which set is better for large families?
The Atlantis Cedar Swing Set is better for large families. It features a raised clubhouse and lower sandbox area. This multi-level design offers diverse play options. The Mount McKinley focuses on climbing and swinging features. If your family needs varied play zones, the Atlantis layout supports more simultaneous activities. Its design encourages different types of play.